SMR vs. VCP

[Runscott]

I have subscribed to VCP since November and use it every day. I use it in conjunction with ebay and searches of the major auction houses, to keep track of prices in my own spreadsheets for issues I'm interested in. It works well.

I find SMR to sometimes have weird information; for instance, it lists most of the T205 cards, but leaves some variations out - seems to be almost random. e.g-only one of the Wilhelm cards is listed. For other variations, it lists the same exact price for both variations, when real market price for the two is drastically different.

Regarding VCP, I find it odd that it is missing so much data, and it seems to be almost random. Sometimes ebay information shows up almost immediately - sometimes never. Same for major auction house data - it's easier sometimes to just google a card to check auction house results. You'll find stuff that way that isn't in VCP at all. As a former programmer, I don't think I could write a software program that would yield such weird results. Having said that, VCP still should give you a good enough idea in most cases, to make a purchase decision.

[Big Six]

Originally Posted by Runscott

I have subscribed to VCP since November and use it every day. I use it in conjunction with ebay and searches of the major auction houses, to keep track of prices in my own spreadsheets for issues I'm interested in. It works well.

I find SMR to sometimes have weird information; for instance, it lists most of the T205 cards, but leaves some variations out - seems to be almost random. e.g-only one of the Wilhelm cards is listed. For other variations, it lists the same exact price for both variations, when real market price for the two is drastically different.

Regarding VCP, I find it odd that it is missing so much data, and it seems to be almost random. Sometimes ebay information shows up almost immediately - sometimes never. Same for major auction house data - it's easier sometimes to just google a card to check auction house results. You'll find stuff that way that isn't in VCP at all. As a former programmer, I don't think I could write a software program that would yield such weird results. Having said that, VCP still should give you a good enough idea in most cases, to make a purchase decision.

Thanks Scott...I'm leaning towards getting VCP...seems like the best option out there...

[vintagetoppsguy]

I've had a few issues with VCP - they ommitted a few of my purchases from earlier last year and they list players as HOFers that are NOT HOFers, but overall they're pretty decent.

[BobbyVCP]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

I've had a few issues with VCP - they ommitted a few of my purchases from earlier last year and they list players as HOFers that are NOT HOFers, but overall they're pretty decent.

We recently made some changes and you should start seeing most if not all BIN and eBay store sales and other auction houses showing up on VCP. As far as little errors such as HOF not or being notated incorrectly it is an easy fix so just click on the Report a Problem button page located on the bottom right side of every page. We have over 5,000,000 pages in our website and we try our best but we are only human. So if you ever see something wrong email me or click on the report an error and we will get it fixed, fast.

[Exhibitman]

I don't know why anyone would give any credence to a price "guide" that deviates from actual price data the way the SMR does; what is it "guiding" you to, how to pay the wrong price for a card? It is as useless as a heap of rat feces as far as I am concerned.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

I don't know why anyone would give any credence to a price "guide" that deviates from actual price data the way the SMR does; what is it "guiding" you to, how to pay the wrong price for a card? It is as useless as a heap of rat feces as far as I am concerned.

You guys aren’t looking at this the right way. SMR actually helps keep prices down. Let me explain. I think we can all agree that the VCP price is lower than the SMR price on most cards. Why is that? Simple, nobody wants to pay book value for a card. Most of us are comfortable paying 70-80% of book value for a card, and most VCP prices are 70-80% of SMR.

Let me give you 3 quick examples. Let’s take a 1962 Topps #5 Koufax, #300 Mays and #320 Aaron, all graded a PSA 6. Each card has a SMR of $100, however the VCP average for those three cards is $71.46, $85.13 and $72.71 respectively.

I guarantee if one (or all) of those cards went up to $200 in the next edition of the SMR, the VCP average would increase as well because people would be willing to pay more if they thought the card was worth more. Likewise, if one (or all) of those cards went down to $75 in the next edition of the SMR, the VCP average would decrease as well as people would pay less if they thought the card was worth less.

In other words, it doesn’t matter what the price says in the SMR because most people don’t want to pay book value for a card. They want to feel like they’re getting a deal. Let’s say for a minute that SMR changed their pricing structure to reflect VCP prices (the price on most cards would go down). Well, the VCP prices would go down shortly thereafter because people wouldn’t feel like they’re getting a deal by paying book value for a card and they would start to pay less.

Anyway, that’s why SMR is necessary. It gives us a starting price and we’re usually willing to pay 70-80% of that price. It doesn’t matter what the SMR price says, VCP average will always be 70-80% of that (on most cards).

Consider it like buying a car. Nobody pays the sticker price for a car. We all know that the dealership is willing to negotiate off that price. We drive out of the dealership feeling good because we feel like we got a deal. Look at it as if SMR is the sticker price and VCP is the driveout price. Sure, the dealerhsip could put their lowest price and the windshield, but then you would feel like you were paying sticker and wouldn't feel like you got a deal.

[rdixon1208]

Great take David. One that I've never heard before. I'm curious though....how does this hold up with prewar cards? I've never opened a SMR.

Bye the way: I was looking for you at the Tristar show Saturday. I don't know if you made it but it was a decent show. Quite a lot of pre-war.